Skip to main content

Where's the Silence?

Recently, was watching an interview of Home Minister P Chidambaram, where on a question posed by NDTV editor, Sonia Singh on the PM's 'silence' on many issues including Lokpal Bill , he remarked- "Many people want the PM to speak, or rise up to the plate, But One has to know and belief in the style of the person."

I have read umpteen editorials in various newspapers on why PM is silent on this issue, why PM always speaks later, and what are the PM's views contentious issues. Whenever a political event unfolds (like that of Baba Ramdev's fast, or may be wikileaks !) bloggers and opinion makers on forums like twitter and facebook, people in news paper columns and on tv shows ask the same stupid question. Yes Stupid Indeed.

I shall now humbly describe, why is it - STUPID !

Post Liberalization, The First stable Govt to complete 5 years of power, was the NDA Government under Atal Bihari Vajpayee. There were few television channels then, very few indeed. FDI in media was limited and the country was still opening up. Scams took place.


Yes a lot of them. Like Operation Westend,Phukhan Commission,Kargil Coffin Scam,Kargil Cess Misuse,Telecom Scam- Pramod Mahajan-Reliance-Arun Shourie-Bailout Package to Private Players,UTI Scam,Cyberspace Infosys Ltd. Scam,Petrol Pump and Gas Agency Allotment Scam, Judeo Scam ,Centaur Hotel Deal, Delhi Land Allotment Scam,HUDCO Scam involving Ananth Kumar,VSNL Disinvestment Scam by Arun Shourie,Arvind Johri-Vajpayee-IT Park Lucknow Scam,Delhi Plot Allotment Scam,Medical Procurement Scam - C P Thakur, BALCO Disinvestment Scam,Jain-Hawala Case -L K Advani and so on

How many times did Atal Bihari Vajpayee came on air and spoke about these scandals? How Many Times did he either defended the Govt or the people involved ? How many PAC's or JPC's were made created for these scams? How many sound bytes did his party offer then?

Vajpayee on many occassions either dropped ministers, changed them or re-instated them (like in the case of Defence Minister George Fernandes, when the problem was a bit serious)

But Did Vajpayee spoke? Or Give Sound Bytes ? Of Course one cannot deny that the oratory skills of Vajpayee were far better than the present incumbent of the job , Dr Manmohan Singh.

Since in Politics- Relative Performance matters, and Voters cast their vote on a ballot paper judging a set of political parties and their representatives- One always compares the two. (This is the reason for bringing Vajpayee into the discussion !)

Now lets shed some light on the present situation.

The UPA-2 Government has completed 2 years of power. FDI in Media has been increased (of course in UPA-1 itself) The 24 hour News channels on TV which had a 'Breaking News' once or twice a day, are now showing 'Breaking News' every single minute. The all affluent middle class which has enjoyed the fruits of Liberalization is now vocal and damn opinionated, with tools like Twitter and Facebook on the touch of a button. They have the power to abuse the system and government more now. From the prices of onions to the policy frame work of the Twelfth 5 year plan - They share their opinions on Everything !
(Of course those who haven't yet received the fruits of liberalization are still gaping at such probabilities and fighting for basic services like banking, ration etc; but that is a different story altogether !)

The UPA-1 Government has given India- Right to Information. Anybody can access information related to Govt. (unless it is classified for security reasons) and can take on the government by filing PILs or applications against erring Govt. servants. (Vajpayee regime never thought of such a novel law, and had kept the system opaque and out of bounds)

So now , the 24x7 media news channels can easily access leaked CAG reports, or file RTI's to nail anybody or to 'expose' the deficiencies in the system. Now people can easily question the PM every single minute on any issue, which may not even concern him.

The PM on his part has tried to adjust to this new India. He has given Two Major interviews/interactions - 1) To All Eminent Newspaper Editors 2) To Editors and Journalists of Electronic Media. Whenever the PM travels abroad, there is always a media session on board in his special flight. According to the PM's official website , Since May 2009, (ie when UPA-2 came to power) the PM has taken 18 such foreign visits .Therefore The PM has spoken to the media not less than 20 times in 2 years. Which I think is still a little less. Now in two years, the PM has given sound bytes on occasions of National importance in functions of Rashtrapati Bhawan and also when heads of state of foreign countries arrive in India. In 2010, itself- All the heads of G-5 countries - UK, US, Russia, China and France paid state level visits to India. The PM spoke on All occasions. So we can easily take the number to almost 30 (assuming that the PM provided his precious sound bytes to our decibel hungry media in functions in Rashtrapati Bhavan)

The Congress Party has had atleast 12 conventions, including the Plenary Session and the 125th Foundation day celebrations in the last 2 years. On every occasion the PM has spoken to the people. Which takes the number to 42

The PM has also spoken to the Nation on Independence Day, Has also gone on air before the Ayodhya verdict. He has also spoken many times in the Parliament. From the debate on Price Rise (Cut Motion) , to issues such as Pakistan, to 2G scam , Debate on Wikileaks etc. The PM always makes it a point to share his views on Budget- whether railways or general.

The PM has also addressed various political rallies in State Elections post 2009. The PM speaks whenever he inaugurates National Projects like T3 Terminal of the Delhi Airport or dedicates Ports or Oil refineries to the Nation.

Adding all this we can easily take our total to a comfortable 60

So in 24 months of UPA Government the PM has spoken 2.5 times a month to either the media or the people- Which is Once in 12 days. Which is certainly not a bad record for a PM who is often labelled as Apolitical, Technocrat and Maintains a Low Profile. A PM who believes in Actions rather than Words.

So where's the Silence? Is it not Misunderstood

Either by Me or By the Media?

You be the Judge !

Comments

Ankur Govani said…
awesome dude!! these hypocrites can't digest the government which works for the needy one.. anyhow i believe that this government is the best till date cos we have seen a lot during UPA-2 which is a sign of a healthy democracy :)
June 29, 2011 at 10:26 AM
Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A Liberal India

Since the time I start understanding India's Politics ( At the age of 14-15 years) I have always formed my opinion on facts . Facts alone. All my writings on blogs and otherwise,even facebook posts and "status updates" based on India's socio-political fabric are facts. Facts are Res ipsa loquitur for me, they always do the talking. So whatever I am writing here in the next few paragraphs would also be build on facts, nothing else. Indian Politics is going through a very challenging time. On one hand there is an almost "discredited" Government in the eyes of the media, "counting its days" mired in Realities of Economics, Realities of Coalition Politics, Realities of an Obstructionist Opposition (to say the least), Realities of Anti-Incumbency. and so on. Neverthless, the Government at the centre is Liberal, Democratic and Secular Yes these 3 terms - Liberal, Democratic and Secular are the soul of India. In school, I was ext...
15 comments
Read more

The First Years: UPA Vs NDA

A Comparative Study : First Year of Modi Government Vs First Year of UPA Government Introduction In a Westminster form of Parliamentary Democracy, it is imperative to constantly gauge the mood of the people. 5 years is a long period for an elected Government to usher reforms, especially fulfilling the promises on which it is elected. The first year of any Government sows the seeds and perhaps lays tangible policy foundations for those promises to be fulfilled. But when an elected Government in its very first year of power fails to do so, especially where people are constantly scrutinizing the elected; it not only loses the faith of the people but puts the country to an uncertain future. The Narendra Modi Government will complete its first year in power this May end. Instead of comparing the 10 years of the previous UPA Government to just 1 year of the present NDA Government, this piece of writing will only compare the first year of UPA with the first year of Mod...
17 comments
Read more

Humbled by the Mandate- Thoughts Unlimited

The people of India have given their mandate- strong and decisive. The Congress party has been reduced to its historical low. The Congress party is humbled by the massive verdict given by the people of India in the favour of Narendra Modi led Bharatiya Janta Party. As a supporter, I am more than willing to own up to the fact that the party which I supported made mistakes after mistakes and was simply out of touch with the reality. Still, we should take some solace with the fact that more than 10.6 Crore people have voted for the Congress (19.3% of voters) There is no level to rock bottom. The Congress party has touched rock bottom, and it will only go upwards from here. A lot of hard work and commitment is required to do that. Some Factoids As a staunch Congress supporter on social media, I agree that there was a ‘Modi wave’ which the Congress party could not even see publically. They could not see, because they were simply out of touch with the reality. Narendra ...
15 comments
Read more